Log in



  • March 07, 2018 11:33 AM | Chris Moore (Administrator)

    by Meaghan Hemmings Kent

    FROM THE ARCHIVES is a series of featured articles from previous Exaggerated Features. This article is a follow up from one of the seminars at the Raleigh Convention and was originally published in the 2009 Post Con Issue. For access to all the Exaggerated Features, join ISCA today.

    At the 2008 NCN convention in Raleigh, I had the privilege of speaking about Legal Matters for the Artist, and it became clear that the issue of the right of publicity is a hot topic for caricature artists. The right of publicity is, in general terms, a person’s exclusive right to bene t from, and the right to control the commercial use of, their name, likeness or persona. What this legal doctrine provides is that to use someone else’s name, likeness or persona, in a commercial way, you need their permission. While keeping in mind that this is a convoluted area of the law without clear guidelines, let’s see if we can break it down a little by answering some of the questions that were raised at the 2008 NCN convention.

    What is the law of the right of publicity?

    Unlike Copyright law, the right of publicity
    is not covered by a Federal statute. Instead, it varies from state to state. Some states have statutes, some states rely on common law (case law) and some states use both. The only certain thing is that every state’s law is different. In addition, determining which state’s (or which country’s) law should apply to your facts can be difficult in itself. There are potentially three bodies of law that can apply: where the person resides (their permanent residence, not just where they have a home), where the alleged unlawful use occurred, or where the user of the image resides.

    What is exempt from the right of publicity? 

    Nearly every state recognizes that use in connection with news, public affairs, sports broadcasts, and political commentary are protected speech that trumps the right of pub- licity. However, when that use becomes com- mercial (which is subjective and determined on a case by case basis) the exemption may no longer apply. Easy examples of commercial use are advertising, sports memorabilia, and products bearing a photo image sold because of that image.

    Is artwork exempt from the right of publicity law? 

    Generally, no. However, there is some case law that has carved out exceptions by nding that the artwork can be covered as First Amendment speech. Note, however, that this exception is not a hard line rule because it requires a subjective balancing of an artist’s right of expression against a person’s right of publicity. An Ohio case decided in 2000 involved Tiger Woods suing an artist for using his image in prints of a montage depicting Tiger playing at the Masters in different poses along with images of other great golfers. There, the artist argued that his prints were art and were not commercial, while Tiger argued that the prints were sports merchandise and were commercial.

    The Ohio court held that the original work and the limited edition prints were protected by the First Amendment because they were a montage that conveyed a message and were not merely posters created from a photograph.

    In a California case decided in 2001, the estate for the Three Stooges sued an artist who had created a charcoal drawing of the Three Stooges and sold the image as litho- graphs and on t-shirts. The California court held against the artist stating that the image was so lifelike that it was not “transformative” enough to enjoy the protection of the First Amendment. In other words, under California law, transformative images are immunized by the First Amendment, but images that were too lifelike were not. The California court went on to explain, that if a person’s image is just raw material for original artwork and the artistic expression is the dominant attribute of the artwork, then the artist’s First Amendment rights will trump the person’s right of publicity. The California court used Andy Warhol portraits as an example of a work where the artist’s rights would supersede the person’s right of publicity. This test, unfortunately, does not provide any de nite guidance because it requires a court to make an aesthetic judg- ment on a case by case basis and different courts can reach different results.

    In one 2003 California case applying this test, the court found that the musicians John and Edgar Winter (the Autumn Brothers) were recognizable in a comic book but that it was transformative because they were depicted as half human and half worm and was there- fore protected. However, a 2003 Missouri court found that the use of the name of a hockey player, Tony Twist, in a comic book was not transformative and was just a ploy to sell more comic books. Whether a caricature, or any artwork, is exempt from the right of publicity law, will depend on an aesthetic evaluation of whether it conveys a message, whether it is “transformative,” or whether it meets some other test that the state decides to apply (because remember, each state has its own law), and will require thorough review of the particular state’s law.

    Are single and original artworks exempt?

    Generally, yes. Many state’s (including Cali- fornia) include an exemption in their right of publicity statutes for single and original works of artwork. However, once copies of that single work are made as prints, even limited edition prints, on t-shirts, on posters, etc. then this exemption falters and the balancing of rights discussed above is required. For example, in the Three Stooges case, the California court noted that the original charcoal did not infringe on the rights of publicity, but the lithographs and t-shirts did.

    Are political figures fair game? 

    No. In most states, the same restrictions apply to use of a politician’s image as to any other person. While news and political commentary are protected speech that generally trumps the right of publicity, commercial use of a politician’s image will raise a red ag. For example, Arnold Schwarzenegger and Rudy Giuliani have both gone after people for use of their image. Arnold targeted a bobble head doll while Rudy threatened to sue PETA for using his image in a mock Got Milk advertisement (“Got prostate cancer?” related to milk consumption allegedly being linked to prostate cancer).

    Are dead celebrities fair game? 

    It depends. Some states have posthumous rights (such as California, Indiana, Oklahoma, Tennes- see, Florida, Kentucky, Illinois) while others do not (New York, where Marilyn Monroe was found to have resided). Even if a state has posthumous rights, states vary on how long those posthumous rights last. For instance, in Tennessee (where Elvis resided), posthumous rights last forever, while in California they last for 70 years and in Florida they last for 40 years.

    What do i do if i want to use a person’s image in a commercial way? 

    If you create a work that you or another party plan to use in a commercial way (like in an advertisement, on products, or mass publication of your artwork), be sure that you have permission to use the likeness of anyone who appears in the work. If the artwork is created for another party, ask them to agree to defend and indemnify you if a dispute does arise. And don’t forget to get it all in writing!

    Meaghan Hemmings Kent is an intellectual property attorney in the Washington, D.C. of ce of Venable LLP. She advises clients on all areas of intellectual property law, including copyright, trademark, patent, trade secret, right of publicity, and domain name law. She can be reached at 202-344-4481 and mhkent@venable.com. The views expressed in this article are those of the author, do not constitute legal advice, and should not be attributed to Venable LLP or its clients. 


  • March 05, 2018 8:28 PM | Tom Faraci (Administrator)

    The winter Post-Con issue of Exaggerated Features is out now! The print version is in mailboxes now, and the PDF is available to  members here. This issue features a round up of all of the winners from the 2017 ISCA convention in Orlando, as well as an interview with the newly-crowned Golden Nosey winner, Manny Avetisyan! Also in this issue: A gallery show of rock and roll caricatures in Cleveland (by Tom Faraci and Derek Brennan), a comic recounting the State Fair of Texas (by Lorin Bernsen and Robert Sundin), and an American caricaturist in Prague (by Sam KingDavis)! Cover art is by our 2016 Golden Nosey winner, Dai Tamura.


    Oh, also, we're on Facebook now.

    Exaggerated Features is included in your ISCA membership.

    Not a member?

    Join today!

  • November 13, 2017 10:32 PM | Tom Faraci (Administrator)

    Stay tuned for more info.

    #iscacon27 #sandiego #california

  • November 13, 2017 10:14 PM | Tom Faraci (Administrator)

    ISCA Con 26 is over! What a week!

    Congratulations to all of this year's winners, especially to Joe Bluhm, Lindsey Olivares, and Manny Avetisyan, who took home the Bronze, Silver, and Gold Noseys, respectively.

    Thank you to all of our speakers and sponsors, and a HUGE thanks to President Matt Zitman, who stepped down this year, handing the ISCA reigns to Chris Moore as we head into 2018. Chris will be joined by returning board members Cory Lally (Vice President), Tom Faraci (Treasurer), and the newly elected Secretary, AJ Jensen.

    Look for a full convention wrap up in the post-con issue of Exaggerated Features!

  • November 12, 2017 4:09 PM | CeCe Holt (Administrator)
  • October 22, 2017 9:53 PM | Tom Faraci (Administrator)

    This year's Pre-Con EF is now available in digital format. Inside you'll find convention rules and the schedule, as well as an interview with guest speaker Tom Fluharty and and wonderful tribute to this year's Hall of Fame inductee, Glenn Ferguson.


    http://caricature.org/Members-only-content
  • September 26, 2017 2:15 PM | Tom Faraci (Administrator)

    Here is the link to the newest issue of Exaggerated Features!! This one is only found online as it has several videos and links found throughout.  


    Check it out and Enjoy! http://caricature.org/Members-only-content


  • September 21, 2017 1:55 AM | Tom Faraci (Administrator)

    For the first time ever, we’re collecting as many of our previous Golden Nosey winners together in one room to answer your questions! Whether you learn something or not, at the very least you’ll be able to bask in their glow and perhaps absorb some of their powers.*



    *Power absorption not guaranteed or likely.

    Register Today!

  • September 21, 2017 1:45 AM | Tom Faraci (Administrator)

    Join us in welcoming David O'Keefe back to the ISCA stage!

    Register Today!

  • August 24, 2017 6:51 PM | CeCe Holt (Administrator)

    Kinyahnah

    Smith

    Calisse

    Adam

    Melissa

    Almariei

    Dan

    Almariei

    Kyle

    Ames

    Carlos

    Ampudia

    Natalia

    Avetisyan

    Manvel

    Avetisyan

    Tad

    Barney

    Bil

    Barrett

    Robert

    Bauer

    Ben

    Bloss

    Joe

    Bluhm

    Mary

    Bluhm

    Derek

    Brennan

    Tom

    Brennan

    Julia

    Brennan

    Marty

    Brinkdopke

    Annie

    Broutman

    Greg

    Brozik

    Becky

    Buckelew

    Dino

    Casterline

    Aaron

    Castricone

    Lu Chih

    Chang

    Mariko

    Chiba

    Chris

    Chua

    John

    Deininger

    Christina

    Denisiuk

    Brian

    Denisiuk

    Lar

    DeSouza

    Dino

    DiArtist

    Steve

    Dorris

    Jeremy

    Drysdale

    Jessica

    Du Preez

    Rob

    Dumo

    Bob

    East

    Chad

    Engle

    Sheena

    Engle

    Bernd

    Ertl

    Casey

    Falco

    Tom

    Faraci

    Glenn

    Ferguson

    JoAnn

    Ferguson

    Joan

    Fleming

    Thomas

    Fluharty

    Robin

    Frey

    Kayla

    Gales

    Billy

    Gallagher

    Alison

    Gelbman

    Michael

    Graessle

    Ron

    Graff

    Jonathan

    Guerzon

    Mike

    Hasson

    Laurel

    Hawkswell

    Jared

    Hobson

    Garrett

    Holt

    Brodie

    Holt

    Xavier

    Holt

    CeCe

    Holt

    Rob

    Hren

    George

    Huante

    Kohta

    Ichinomiya

    Eri

    Ikeda

    Yashiko

    Ikegami

    Ai

    Ishii

    Yasushi

    Ito

    AJ

    Jensen

    Alani

    Jimenez

    Tami

    Johnson

    Heather

    Joy

    Miyuki

    Kaga

    Darren

    Kennedy

    Sam

    KingDavis

    Wally

    Kissel III

    Ken

    Knafou

    Diane

    Laflamme

    John

    Lafree

    Cory

    Lally

    Herve

    Leveillee

    Jime

    Litwalk

    Mel

    Lothrop

    Sarah

    Macy

    Jeff

    Mandell

    Jordan

    Martin

    Martin

    Martin

    Sebastian

    Martin

    Patrick

    Martinez

    Dan

    McMahan

    Jeff

    Metcalf

    Kosuke

    Miyagi

    Kazuyoki

    Miyajima

    Kira

    Moore

    Chris

    Moore

    Fia

    Moore

    Susan

    Moreno

    Bobbie

    Morris

    Renbert

    Mortimer



    Eve

    Myles

    Kage

    Nakanishi

    Liz

    Nava

    Ken

    Negran

    Joey

    Nieves

    Nick

    Nix

    Patty

    Nix

    Keita

    Noda

    Chihiro

    Noguchi

    Kunikazu

    Noguchi

    David

    O'Keefe

    Lindsey

    Olivares

    Elizabeth

    Pankey

    Roger

    Pankey

    Keelan

    Parham

    Brady

    Parham

    Barbie

    Parham

    Victor

    Patterson

    Paula

    Petlowany

    Stacy

    Pierce

    Richard

    Powell

    Antwan

    Ramar

    Ruben

    Ramirez

    John

    Read

    Jeff

    Redford

    Damon

    Renthrope

    Tom

    Richmond

    Joachim

    Rick

    Rowdy

    Roadfeldt

    Lars-Erik

    Robinson

    Jennifer

    Rolfsema

    Luis

    Rosario

    Ashley

    Rowland

    Gwenda

    Saunders

    Chelsey

    Schaefer

    Ryan

    Secora

    Mike

    Sesay

    Lisa

    Shaffer

    Adnan

    Shati

    Dave

    Smith

    Tony

    Smith

    Shouta

    Sora

    Marie

    Sturman

    Larry

    Takvam

    Christopher

    Tamlyn

    Ali

    Thome

    Jorge

    Torrealba

    Kim

    Truedson

    Martha

    Trupp

    Chain

    Tsay

    Teague

    Tysseling

    Ranielle

    Valentin

    Sergio

    Vargas

    Brian

    Vasilik

    Julie

    Veen

    Birgit

    Vlk

    Dan

    Vottero

    Bernd

    Weidenauer

    Michael

    White

    Yonie

    Woo

    SIKISSY

    Yonemori

    Marilyn

    Zishka

    Matt

    Zitman






Forum updates

Featured member

SPONSORED BY

Thank you to  our 2018 Sponsors! 2019 Sponsors TBA          

Powered by Wild Apricot Membership Software